Uni Reading List
Index / 001 EN
Classical Indian Philosophy: A History of Philosophy without Any Gaps, Volume 5 cover

Philosophy

Philosophy

Classical Indian Philosophy: A History of Philosophy without Any Gaps, Volume 5

Peter Adamson; Jonardon Ganeri

The fifth volume of Peter Adamson's History of Philosophy without Any Gaps series, written with Jonardon Ganeri. In short, readable chapters it traces philosophy in ancient and classical India, presenting the major schools and their debates as rigorous philosophy and following the arguments between Buddhist, Jain, and Brahmanical thinkers.

Prerequisites: No background in Indian philosophy or Sanskrit is needed; some general experience of philosophical argument helps.

Difficulty Level
Intermediate
Academic Level
Undergraduate
indian philosophybuddhismnyayavedantahistory of philosophy

01 / Reading Guide

Reading Guide

Citation

Adamson, P., & Ganeri, J. (2022). Classical Indian Philosophy: A History of Philosophy without Any Gaps, Volume 5. Oxford University Press.

Chapter Summary

The book has 49 short chapters in four parts: "Origins", "The Age of the Sutra", "Buddhists and Jainas" and "Beyond Ancient India". It grew out of Peter Adamson's podcast series, and the publisher describes it as a self-standing volume that can be read without the other volumes of the series. The publisher's description adds that the opening part presents philosophy as a form of life aimed at liberation from suffering. Chapter titles below are given as listed by the publisher, without diacritics.

Part I, Origins: Chapters 1–2

"Begin at the End: Introduction to Indian Philosophy" and "Scriptures, Schools, and Systems: A Historical Overview". These two chapters orient the reader to the tradition and to its main texts and schools before the history begins.

Chapters 3–6: Vedic period, Upanishads, self and karma

"Kingdom for a Horse: India in the Vedic Period", "Hide and Seek: The Upanisads", "Indra's Search: The Self in the Upanisads" and "You Are What You Do: Karma in the Upanisads". The earliest extant literature, then the Upanishads' treatment of the self and of karma.

Chapter 7: Case Worker: Panini's Grammar

A single chapter on Panini's grammar. Language returns as a theme in chapters 18 and 21.

Chapters 8–9: The Buddha

"Suffering and Smiling: The Buddha" and "Crossover Appeal: The Nature of the Buddha's Teaching".

Chapters 10–11: Politics and women

"Carry a Big Stick: Ancient Indian Political Thought" and "Better Half: Women in Ancient India". These chapters cover the themes of political authority and the status of women that the publisher highlights.

Chapters 12–14: Epics and non-violence

"Grand Illusion: Dharma and Deception in the Mahabharata", "World on a String: The Bhagavad-gita" and "Mostly Harmless: Non-Violence".

Part II, The Age of the Sutra: Chapters 15–21

"A Tangled Web: The Age of the Sutra", "When in Doubt: The Rise of Skepticism", "Master of Ceremonies: Jaimini's Mimamsa-sutra", "Innocent Until Proven Guilty: Mimamsa on Knowledge and Language", "Source Code: Badarayana's Vedanta-sutra", "No Two Ways About It: Sankara and Advaita Vedanta" and "Communication Breakdown: Bhartrhari on Language". Skepticism, Mimamsa and Vedanta, including the monism of Advaita, and a second chapter on language.

Chapters 22–24: Samkhya, medicine and Yoga

"The Theory of Evolution: Isvarakrsna's Samkhya-karika", "Who Wants to Live Forever? Early Ayurvedic Medicine" and "Practice Makes Perfect: Patanjali's Yoga-sutra".

Chapters 25–28: Nyaya

"Where There's Smoke There's Fire: Gautama's Nyaya-sutra", "What You See Is What You Get: Nyaya on Perception", "Standard Deductions: Nyaya on Reasoning" and "The Truth Shall Set You Free: Nyaya on the Mind". Four chapters on the logical and epistemological school.

Chapters 29–31: Vaisesika and time

"Fine Grained Analysis: Kanada's Vaisesika-sutra", "The Whole Story: Vaisesika on Complexity and Causation" and "A Day in the Life: Theories of Time".

Chapters 32–33: Naturalism and materialism

"The Wolf's Footprint: Indian Naturalism" and "Mind out of Matter: Materialist Theories of the Self". The materialist critics, including the Carvaka school named in the publisher's description.

Part III, Buddhists and Jainas: Chapters 34–39

"We Beg to Differ: The Buddhists and Jainas", then Nagarjuna on emptiness, change and the tetralemma ("It All Depends", "Motion Denied", "No Four Ways About It"), and the Jaina theory of standpoints and truth ("Taking Perspective", "Well Qualified").

Chapters 40–44: Yogacara, no-self and Dignaga

"Change of Mind: Vasubandhu and Yogacara Buddhism", "Who's Pulling Your Strings? Buddhaghosa on No-Self and Autonomy", and three chapters on Dignaga: "Under Construction: Dignaga on Perception and Language", "Follow the Evidence: Dignaga's Logic" and "Doors of Perception: Dignaga on Consciousness".

Part IV, Beyond Ancient India: Chapters 45–49

"In Good Taste: The Rasa Aesthetic Theory", "Learn by Doing: Tantra", "Looking East: Indian Influence on Greek Thought", "The Buddha and I: Indian Influence on Islamic and European Thought" and "What Happened Next: Indian Philosophy After Dignaga". Aesthetics, Tantra, the question of Indian influence on Greek and later thought, and a closing chapter on what follows Dignaga.

Key Concepts

Chapters 1–14: Origins

  • Self and karma in the Upanishads: chapters 5 and 6 treat the self and karma as central themes.
  • Dharma and non-violence: chapters 12 to 14 take up dharma in the Mahabharata, the Bhagavad-gita and non-violence.

Chapters 15–33: The age of the sutra

  • Sutra traditions: foundational texts for schools such as Mimamsa, Vedanta, Samkhya, Yoga, Nyaya and Vaisesika.
  • Advaita Vedanta: the monism treated in chapter 20.
  • Nyaya epistemology and logic: chapters 26 and 27 cover perception and reasoning.
  • Materialist and naturalist thought: the Carvaka school and related theories of the self.

Chapters 34–49: Buddhists, Jainas and beyond

  • Emptiness and the tetralemma: Nagarjuna's critique of "non-dependent" concepts.
  • Standpoints: the Jaina epistemology the publisher singles out.
  • Dignaga: perception, language, logic and consciousness, in the no-self philosophy of mind the publisher mentions.
  • Rasa and Tantra: traditions often omitted from overviews of Indian thought.

Critical Analysis

Strengths

  • Breadth beyond the usual schools. The publisher stresses that the book also covers the Carvaka school, Tantra and aesthetic theory, and themes such as non-violence, political authority and the status of women. The table of contents confirms separate chapters on politics, women, Ayurveda, naturalism, rasa and Tantra.
  • Short, self-contained chapters. At 49 chapters in a volume of roughly 400 pages, chapters are brief, and the publisher describes them as short and lively. A reader can take a school, a thinker or a theme in one sitting.
  • No prior knowledge assumed. The publisher presents the volume as accessible to beginners and independent of the rest of the series, which makes it a workable first book on the subject.
  • Two authors. The publisher's biographies describe Adamson as the host of the History of Philosophy podcast and Ganeri as a Fellow of the British Academy whose work draws on several philosophical traditions.

Limitations

  • Brief treatment of each school. Averaged over the whole book, each chapter has fewer than ten pages, so arguments are sketched rather than reconstructed. For depth on Buddhist philosophy in particular, a dedicated study is needed.
  • A narrative history, not a source collection. The publisher's material describes a lively guide to schools and debates, not an anthology of translated texts, so readers must go elsewhere for the primary sources.
  • A compressed ending. Later Indian philosophy is covered in one closing chapter, "What Happened Next: Indian Philosophy After Dignaga", and 44 of the 49 chapters end with Dignaga or earlier, so the book is weightiest on that period.
  • Catalogue page counts differ. OUP India lists 432 pages and Google Books 397, so check the copy in hand when assigning page ranges.

Where It Fits in the Course

This is the survey in the course. Sue Hamilton's Indian Philosophy: A Very Short Introduction is a briefer overview of the same ground that explains how Indian thinkers tied questions about reality and knowledge to a quest for liberation. Michael Carrithers's The Buddha: A Very Short Introduction focuses on early Buddhism and fits alongside chapters 8 and 9.

Mark Siderits's Buddhism as Philosophy goes much deeper on the Buddhist side: it treats non-self, Abhidharma, Yogacara, Madhyamaka and Dignaga's epistemology, so Nagarjuna, Vasubandhu and Dignaga appear in both books (chapters 35–44 here). A sensible sequence is to read Adamson and Ganeri for the map and then move to Siderits for argument. Bryan Van Norden's Introduction to Classical Chinese Philosophy and A. C. Graham's Disputers of the Tao cover Chinese thought and make a counterpart to this book for a comparative course.

How to Use This Book

The book suits first-time readers, students of religion or South Asian studies, and philosophers who want Indian thought set beside the Western tradition. No Sanskrit is needed.

A practical plan:

  • Orientation: chapters 1 and 2, then Part I at your own pace.
  • Core for a philosophy course: chapters 4–6 on the Upanishads, chapters 8–9 on the Buddha, one chapter on each of the Mimamsa, Vedanta, Nyaya and Vaisesika schools, and chapters 35–37 and 42–43 on Nagarjuna and Dignaga.
  • Optional: the chapters on politics, women, medicine, time, rasa and Tantra, which suit a reader interested in the wider culture.
  • Ending: chapters 47–49 on influence and what followed, for readers who care about the history of ideas.

Because the chapters are short and independent, assign clusters rather than the whole book. Pair them with translated primary texts, and consider the related podcast episodes on the same topics as a review aid.