01 / Reading Guide
Reading Guide
Citation
Carley, P., Mees, I. M., & Collins, B. (2025). Practical English Phonetics and Phonology: A Resource Book for Students (5th ed.). Routledge.
Chapter Summary
The fifth edition, in the Routledge English Language Introductions series, runs to about 250 pages. Its text is organised in three sections of short units (A1–A10, B1–B8, C1–C6), roughly 200 pages in all, followed by a glossary, further reading, references, the IPA chart and an index. The publisher's main change for this edition is that British and American English are treated side by side throughout; the description also mentions new exercises, diagrams and references, and an updated companion website with recordings of speakers of 25 accent varieties, answer keys and audio for the activities. The structure has changed from the fourth edition (2019): units on English worldwide, on connected speech and transcription, and on English spelling no longer appear as separate units, and the consonant and vowel material is divided into more, shorter units. Beverley Collins, who died in 2014, remains a credited author.
Section A: Segments (A1–A3: British and American English; Phoneme, allophone, syllable; How we produce speech)
The opening units set out the two reference accents, the notions of phoneme, allophone and syllable, and the mechanics of speech production. Together they take about 23 pages.
Section A: Segments (A4–A6: Consonant possibilities; English obstruents; English sonorants)
A general survey of the consonants the human vocal tract can produce is followed by the English consonants, divided into obstruents (the longest of these units, about 12 pages) and sonorants.
Section A: Segments (A7–A10: Vowel possibilities; The English short vowels; The English long vowels; The English diphthongs and vowels + /r/)
The same pattern for vowels: first the possible vowel qualities, then the English short vowels, long vowels, and diphthongs together with vowel + /r/ combinations.
Section B: Supra-segmental features (B1–B5: Phoneme and syllable revisited; Word stress; Sentence stress; Features of connected speech; Speech melody)
Section B returns to the phoneme and syllable and moves above the single sound: word stress, sentence stress, the features of connected speech (the publisher mentions weak forms, rhythm and "the surprises of connected speech"), and speech melody, which at about 11 pages is the main unit on intonation.
Section B: Supra-segmental features (B6–B8: Pronunciation change; Teaching English pronunciation; Learning a foreign language)
Three applied units: how pronunciation changes, the teaching of English pronunciation, and learning a foreign language. B8 is the longest unit in the book, about 24 pages; the publisher's description says the book gives descriptions of the sound systems of Spanish, Italian, French, German, Polish and Japanese.
Section C: Accents of English (C1–C6)
C1 compares the two reference accents, GB and GA. C2 and C3 cover the accents of England and the Celtic-influenced varieties of the British Isles; C4–C6 survey world varieties: North America, the Southern Hemisphere, and second-language varieties and creole-influenced speech. The units are short (4–14 pages) and rely on the accent recordings on the companion website.
Key Concepts
Section A: Segments
- GB and GA: the British and American reference accents described side by side throughout the book.
- Phoneme and allophone: the contrastive sound units of a language and their positional variants.
- Obstruents and sonorants: the two broad classes into which the English consonants are divided.
- Short vowels, long vowels and diphthongs: the groups in which the English vowels are presented.
Section B: Supra-segmental features
- Word stress and sentence stress: prominence within words and within utterances.
- Connected speech: what happens to sounds in continuous speech, including weak forms and rhythm.
- Speech melody: intonation, treated as part of the supra-segmental system.
- Pronunciation change: how the pronunciation of English shifts over time.
Section C: Accents of English
- Accent variation: systematic differences between varieties of English, starting from GB and GA.
- Second-language and creole-influenced varieties: English as spoken in places where it is a second language or has creole influence.
Critical Analysis
Strengths
- British and American English together. The publisher presents the parallel treatment of GB and GA as new to this edition, and units A1 and C1 are organised around the comparison. This makes the book usable for students who need either model, or both.
- Practice at every step. The series promises activities, study questions and sample analyses, and Alan Cruttenden, quoted by the publisher about the fourth edition, named the exercises "provided at every step of the way" as one of its real strengths; answer keys are on the companion website.
- Recorded accents. The companion website's samples of 25 accent varieties, from Britain, Ireland, North America, Australia, New Zealand, South Africa, India, Singapore and West Africa, make Section C more than a written description. Cruttenden called the survey of accents brief but unequalled; Richard Cauldwell, also quoted by the publisher, valued the accompanying audio.
- Short units. Most units run to between 4 and 12 pages, so the book divides easily into weekly reading.
Limitations
- English-focused. Although B8 and the descriptions of other languages give a first look at foreign sound systems, the book is about English and is not a general phonetics course: the IPA chart is included in the back matter, but the units concentrate on English sounds.
- Phonology is light. As the title's "practical" suggests, there is no unit on phonological theory or on analysing sound patterns from data; phonology appears through the phoneme, the syllable and stress.
- Little acoustics. Speech production has its own unit (A3), but no unit deals with the acoustic analysis of speech.
- Brief accent units. The Section C units are short, about four to six pages for each world region in C4–C6, so they introduce accents rather than describe them in detail.
Where It Fits in the Course
This is the most practical, English-focused book in the course and a sound first text for students of English language, English teaching or TEFL. Peter Ladefoged and Keith Johnson's A Course in Phonetics is the general-phonetics counterpart: it teaches IPA transcription with examples from languages around the world and covers acoustics as well as production. Students of linguistics, rather than of English, should read it alongside or after this book.
For phonology, David Odden's Introducing Phonology teaches the analysis of sound patterns from data in many languages, which this book does not attempt, and John Clark and colleagues' An Introduction to Phonetics and Phonology is a broader survey that combines articulatory and acoustic phonetics with phonological theory. Keith Johnson's Acoustic and Auditory Phonetics and Peter Ladefoged's Elements of Acoustic Phonetics cover the physical signal and its perception, topics left aside here.
How to Use This Book
The book suits first-year students of English language and linguistics, trainee English teachers, and advanced learners who want to understand and improve their own pronunciation. No previous study of phonetics is assumed.
A reading plan:
- Choose a reference accent first. Read A1, then follow either GB or GA consistently through Sections A and B, noting the other accent's differences as you go.
- Core: A1–A10 in order, then B1–B5. These units give the sound system and the supra-segmental features needed for transcription.
- For teachers: add B7 and B8; B8 is also useful for anyone whose first language is among those the book describes.
- Accents: read C1 after Section A, and use C2–C6 with the recordings, ideally one region per week.
- Optional: B6 on pronunciation change, for students interested in the history of English.
Do the activities with the audio rather than from the page alone, check answers on the companion website, and practise transcription regularly. Listen to the accent samples several times, first for overall impression and then for the specific features the unit describes. Follow with Ladefoged and Johnson for general phonetics or Odden for phonology.
