The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction

  1. Home
  2. Docs
  3. LSE
  4. LSE Law School
  5. The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction

The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction


Loughlin, M. (2013). The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction. Oxford University Press.

Author and Publication Information

Author: Martin Loughlin
Publication Date: 2013
Publisher: Oxford University Press

Intellectual & Historical Context

Martin Loughlin is a distinguished scholar in public law and legal theory, with a particular focus on constitutional theory and the political dynamics underpinning constitutional arrangements. His work “The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction” provides an insightful examination of the British constitutional system, which stands out for its unique nature as an unwritten constitution evolving through customs, statutes, and common law rather than a single written document. Published in 2013, this book addresses contemporary debates on constitutional reform, the historical evolution of the British constitution, and its relevance in modern governance.

The intellectual backdrop of this work is rooted in the broader discourse of constitutional theory and political science, particularly the tension between traditional and modern understandings of constitutional governance. Historically, the British constitution has been celebrated for its adaptability and evolutionary nature, allowing for stability and incremental reforms without revolutionary upheavals. However, in the contemporary context, this traditional system faces scrutiny and calls for modernization to address issues of legitimacy, coherence, and functionality in a rapidly changing political landscape.

Thesis Statement

Loughlin’s central thesis is that the British constitution, once heralded as a model of gradual and peaceful political evolution, now faces significant challenges that question its efficacy and legitimacy. He argues that while the unwritten and flexible nature of the constitution has historically been a source of strength, it now requires critical examination and possibly substantial reform to align with modern democratic principles and the needs of a contemporary state.

Key Concepts

1. Traditional vs. Modern Constitution

Loughlin contrasts the traditional British constitution, which is unwritten and evolves organically, with the modern concept of a written constitution that explicitly outlines the framework of governance and fundamental laws.

2. Parliamentary Sovereignty

A cornerstone of the British constitution, parliamentary sovereignty denotes the supreme legal authority of Parliament to create or end any law. Loughlin examines how this principle has adapted over time and its implications for modern governance.

3. Constitutional Reform

Loughlin discusses various waves of constitutional reform, particularly focusing on the period from the late 20th century to the early 21st century, including devolution, human rights legislation, and attempts to modernize the House of Lords and electoral systems.

4. Civil Liberties

The protection and expansion of civil liberties within the framework of the British constitution is a critical area of analysis. Loughlin explores how civil liberties have been upheld or challenged in different historical periods and the role of constitutional mechanisms in safeguarding these rights.

5. Identity and Constitutional Values

Loughlin delves into the relationship between national identity, cultural values, and the constitution, questioning whether the traditional constitutional values still resonate with the contemporary British society.

Chapter Summaries

Chapter 1: What Constitution?

Loughlin begins by discussing the concept of a constitution and the peculiarities of the British constitutional system. He addresses the historical praise for the British constitution as “matchless” for balancing monarchy, aristocracy, and democracy. The chapter contrasts the traditional unwritten British constitution with modern written constitutions. Loughlin also introduces key questions about the contemporary relevance and functionality of the British constitution, emphasizing the need to understand its historical development to grasp current challenges.

Chapter 2: Writing the Constitution

This chapter explores the reluctance of the British to codify their constitution in a single document. Loughlin examines the historical evolution of constitutional practices through custom, common law, and statutes. He discusses influential figures such as Edmund Burke and their arguments for the traditional constitution. The chapter also introduces the modern idea of a constitution, exemplified by the United States, where the constitution is a written, foundational document. Loughlin highlights the tension between traditional British constitutionalism and the rationalist, written constitutions of other modern states.

Chapter 3: Parliamentary Government

Loughlin delves into the core structure of the British constitution—parliamentary government. He discusses the historical development of Parliament and its central role in the British political system. The chapter explains the principle of parliamentary sovereignty, where Parliament is the supreme legal authority. Loughlin also explores the checks and balances within the British system, including the role of the monarchy, the House of Lords, and the judiciary. The historical shifts in power dynamics and the evolving functions of these institutions are analyzed in detail.

Chapter 4: The Expansion and Contraction of the English State

This chapter examines the territorial evolution of the British state, including the union with Scotland and Ireland and the subsequent formation of the United Kingdom. Loughlin discusses the expansion of the British Empire and its impact on constitutional practices. He also addresses the decolonization process and the contraction of the British state in the 20th century. The chapter explores how these territorial changes have influenced the constitution and the challenges of integrating multiple nations within a single constitutional framework.

Chapter 5: Civil Liberty

Loughlin focuses on the protection of civil liberties within the British constitutional framework. He traces the historical development of civil liberties, from Magna Carta to contemporary human rights legislation. The chapter examines key statutes and legal precedents that have shaped civil liberties in Britain. Loughlin discusses the balance between maintaining order and protecting individual freedoms, highlighting the role of the judiciary and parliamentary legislation in this dynamic.

Chapter 6: Whither the Constitution?

In the concluding chapter, Loughlin reflects on the current state and future of the British constitution. He addresses the contemporary challenges facing the constitution, including political dissatisfaction, calls for constitutional reform, and debates over the necessity of a written constitution. Loughlin examines the impact of globalization, European integration, and devolution on the British constitutional system. He questions whether the traditional unwritten constitution can adapt to modern demands or if a fundamental constitutional overhaul is needed.

Key Quotes and Significance

Key Quotes

“The British clearly have a system of government, a set of rules regulating the exercise of political power. But the idea of a ‘constitution’ connotes something more.”

  • Significance: This quote underscores the central argument of Loughlin’s book—that a constitution is not merely a collection of rules but embodies deeper values and practices that define political life. It sets the stage for examining whether these values and practices still hold relevance and authority in contemporary Britain.

“The modern concept of a constitution has since been adopted across the world. Nearly 200 nation-states, along with many sub-national units (provinces, states, etc.) in federal regimes, now have written constitutions of the modern type.”

  • Significance: This quote highlights the global prevalence of written constitutions and positions the British constitution as an outlier. It raises questions about the advantages and disadvantages of maintaining an unwritten constitution in an era where codified constitutions are the norm.

“The great virtue of the ‘matchless constitution’ was its ability to reconcile order and liberty: the British constitution aspired to be the ‘constitution of liberty’.”

  • Significance: Loughlin emphasizes the historical strength of the British constitution in balancing order and liberty, a crucial aspect of its traditional acclaim. This balance is critical in evaluating the current state of the constitution and its ability to protect civil liberties in the modern context.

“What remains of the traditional constitution? The concluding chapter brings together the primary concerns of the preceding chapters: the incipient Rationalism of writtenness, the waning of parliamentary authority, the loss of identity inherent in changing territorial forms of the state, the whittling away of civil liberty.”

  • Significance: This quote encapsulates the critical issues facing the British constitution today. It indicates Loughlin’s comprehensive approach in assessing the constitution’s capacity to adapt to contemporary challenges while maintaining its traditional values.

Significance & Impact

Intellectual Significance

Martin Loughlin’s The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction provides an incisive analysis of one of the world’s oldest and most complex constitutional systems. His work is significant in the field of constitutional theory for several reasons:

  1. Theoretical Clarity: Loughlin brings clarity to the distinction between traditional and modern constitutional concepts, enriching the discourse on constitutionalism. His exploration of the British constitution’s unwritten nature offers a counterpoint to the predominance of written constitutions, challenging scholars to reconsider the value and function of constitutional forms.
  2. Historical Contextualization: By situating the British constitution within its historical evolution, Loughlin demonstrates how historical contexts shape constitutional practices and values. This historical approach is essential for understanding contemporary debates on constitutional reform and modernization.
  3. Critical Reflection: Loughlin’s critical perspective on the adaptability and legitimacy of the British constitution invites deeper reflection on its future. His examination of the pressures from globalization, European integration, and internal political dynamics provides a nuanced understanding of the current constitutional crisis and potential paths forward.

Practical Impact

1. Policy and Reform:

Loughlin’s analysis has practical implications for policymakers and reform advocates. His identification of key issues—such as the need for clearer constitutional codification, the balance between parliamentary sovereignty and civil liberties, and the integration of diverse national identities within the UK—can guide constitutional reforms aimed at enhancing legitimacy, coherence, and functionality.

2. Public Understanding:

By offering a concise yet comprehensive introduction to the British constitution, Loughlin’s book serves as an educational tool for the public. It helps demystify the complexities of the unwritten constitution, fostering a more informed citizenry capable of engaging in meaningful dialogue about constitutional issues.

3. Comparative Constitutionalism:

Loughlin’s work contributes to the comparative study of constitutions by highlighting the unique features and challenges of the British system. This comparative perspective can inform constitutional design and reform efforts in other countries, particularly those grappling with the balance between tradition and modernization.


Martin Loughlin’s The British Constitution: A Very Short Introduction is a vital contribution to the study of constitutional law and theory. It offers a critical and historical perspective on the British constitution, highlighting its unique characteristics and contemporary challenges. By addressing the need for potential reforms and the pressures of modern governance, Loughlin provides a roadmap for understanding and possibly rethinking the British constitutional framework in the 21st century.

Post a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *